| Year | Student | High School | Team | College or University |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2020 | DeVante Embrey-Banks | York Suburban | Boys | Lock Haven University |
| 2020 | Madelynn Barley | York Suburban | Boys | Bloomsburg University |
| 2020 | Anthony Brown | York Suburban | Boys | SUNY College of Environmental Science and Forestry |
| 2020 | RJ Marquis | York Suburban | Boys | University of Alabama- Tuscaloosa |
| 2020 | Max Reinecker | York Suburban | Boys | University of Pittsburgh |
| 2020 | Andrew Schultz | York Suburban | Boys | University of Massachusetts |
| 2020 | Chris Spellman | York Suburban | Boys | Penn State University |
| 2020 | Lauren Wallace | York Suburban | Boys | Elizabethtown College |
| 2020 | Cheyenne Proctor | Gettysburg | Girls | PSU Mont Alto |
| 2020 | Madison Proctor | Gettysburg | Girls | PSU Mont Alto |
| 2020 | Lily Natter | Gettysburg | Girls | University of Pittsburgh |
| 2020 | Taylor Richardson | Gettysburg | Girls | Delaware Valley |
| 2019 | Jaren Rex | New Oxford | Boys | Virginia Tech |
| 2019 | Chase Nell | New Oxford | Boys | Drexel |
| 2019 | Justin Gruver | New Oxford | Boys | Millersville |
| 2019 | Brian Klunk | New Oxford | Boys | Icon Collective |
| 2019 | Cameron Krebs | New Oxford | Boys | Elizabethtown |
| 2019 | Auden Ledden | New Oxford | Boys | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| 2019 | Jae Fitch | York High | Girls | York College |
| 2019 | Adrionna Harris | York High | Girls | University of Jacksonville |
| 2018 | Kennedy McKee | York Suburban | Girls | St. Francis University |
| 2018 | Briaunna Embrey-Banks | York Suburban | Girls | York College |
| 2018 | Gianna Batty-Harrison | York Suburban | Girls | Lock Haven University |
| 2018 | Katherine Mooney | York Suburban | Girls | University of Florida |
| 2018 | Ali Reinecker | York Suburban | Girls | University of Pittsburgh |
| 2018 | Joshua Cuddy | South Western | Boys | Flagler College |
| 2018 | Logan Kemp | South Western | Boys | Kutztown University |
| 2018 | Trevor Bean | South Western | Boys | Penn State University |
| 2018 | Ryan Luke | South Western | Boys | Goucher College |
| 2018 | Brady Twyman | South Western | Boys | York College |
| 2017 | Zachary Rudsill | New Oxford | Boys | Lebanon Valley Vollege |
| 2017 | Trevor Floyd | New Oxford | Boys | Wilson Collwge |
| 2017 | Israel Collazo | New Oxford | Boys | Susquehanna University |
| 2017 | Benjamin Lehman | New Oxford | Boys | York College |
| 2017 | Jordin Brown | New Oxford | Boys | PSU York |
| 2017 | Tanner Myers | New Oxford | Boys | Coastal Carolina University |
| 2017 | Brandon Prichard | New Oxford | Boys | Millersville University |
| 2017 | Elizabeth Burke | Bigerville | Girls | Ursinus College |
| 2017 | Allison Sowers | Bigerville | Girls | Bloomsburg University |
| 2017 | Maddie Kuhn | Bigerville | Girls | PSU Mt Alto |
| 2017 | Elizabeth Shreve | Bigerville | Girls | York College |
| 2017 | Courtney Taylor | Bigerville | Girls | York College |
| 2016 | Kyle Krout | Hanover | Boys | Juanitia |
| 2016 | Will McQueen | Hanover | Boys | St. Joseph’s University |
| 2016 | Ben Hutton | Hanover | Boys | University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown |
| 2016 | Saranda Gerlach | Hanover | Boys | West Virginia University |
| 2016 | LilyAnn Yoakum | Susquehannock | Girls | York College |
| 2016 | Ashley Stone | Susquehannock | Girls | Shippensburg University |
| 2016 | Victoria Acton | Susquehannock | Girls | Philadelphia University |
| 2015 | Donte Grim | York County School of Technology | Boys | HACC |
| 2015 | Keevon Rice | York County School of Technology | Boys | Pittsburgh Technical Institute |
| 2015 | Rebecca Isaac | Biglerville | Girls | Messiah College |
| 2015 | Madeline Wenk | Biglerville | Girls | Pennsylvania College of Technology |
| 2014 | Neil Murren | Bermudian Springs | Boys | Messiah College |
| 2014 | Zachary D. Sanni | Bermudian Springs | Boys | Bridgewater College |
| 2014 | Makenzie Fancher | Susquehannock | Girls | Christopher Newport College |
| 2014 | Abbey Barnhart | Susquehannock | Girls | Lebanon Valley College |
| 2013 | Tim Frey | Susquehannock | Boys | Rochester Institute of Technology |
| 2013 | Leah Deter | Susquehannock | Girls | University of Delaware |
| 2012 | Dylan Keller | York Suburban | Boys | Temple University |
| 2012 | Karli McFatridge | York Catholic | Girls | Millersville University |
| 2011 | Shayla Lupian | Biglerville | Girls | Shippensburg University |
| 2011 | Bree Wallen | Bermudian Springs | Boys | HACC |
| 2010 | Megan Mahon | Spring Grove | Girls | Shippensburg Univ. |
| 2010 | Jordan Epler | Bermudian Springs | Boys | James Madison Univ. |
| 2009 | Kara Snyder | Spring Grove | Girls | York College |
| 2009 | Allison Bobb | Biglerville | Boys | Indiana Univ. of PA |
| 2008 | Chelsea Homes | Susquehannock | Girls | Juniata College |
| 2008 | Dashaun Davis | William Penn | Boys | Clemson |
| 2007 | Samantha Crowder | Biglerville | Girls | Malone College |
| 2007 | Mathew Warner | Bermudian Springs | Boys | Elizabethtown College |
| 2006 | Katy Isennock | Susquehannock | Girls | Goucher College |
| 2006 | Ben Lerew | Bermudian Springs | Boys | Taylor University |
| 2005 | Kaitlin Brody | Susquehannock | Girls | Mercyhurst College |
| 2005 | Ryan Lehr | Bermudian Springs | Boys | Millersville Univ. of PA |
| 2004 | Sadie Mummert | Littlestown | Girls | Wittenberg Univ |
| 2004 | Greg Vojcsik | Susquehannock | Boys | Graceland College |
| 2003 | Lauren Beck | Susquehannock | Girls | Shippensburg University |
| 2003 | Patrick Lannon | Susquehannock | Boys | Elizabethtown College |
| 2002 | Andrea Fry | Littlestown | Girls | Carol County Community College |
| 2002 | Matt Riddle | Susquehannock | Boys | Bloomsburg University |
| 2001 | Audrey Bare | Susquehannock | Girls | Univ. Delaware |
| 2001 | Andrew Kern | South Western | Boys | James Madison Univ. |
Mission: To Promote Sportsmanship